Repairing or Replacing Your Garage Door
When your garage door starts acting up, the question on every homeowner’s mind is simple — Should I repair or replace? Living near Monterey and Santa Cruz, CA, where ocean air and weather conditions can wear on garage doors over time, this decision can have a direct impact on your home’s security, energy efficiency, and curb appeal.
Pro Tip: If repairs are under 50% of the cost of a new door and your current door is in decent condition, a repair is usually the better option. However, if you're spending hundreds regularly on repairs, replacement offers long-term savings and peace of mind.
When Repairing Is Cheaper (and Makes Sense)
-
Minor damage like a broken spring, frayed cable, off-track door, or damaged panel.
-
Your opener is fine, and the door still has good structural integrity.
-
Cosmetic issues (like dents or scratches) that don’t affect functionality.
-
Parts are still available for your specific door model.
-
The door isn’t that old—less than 10–15 years is usually a good benchmark.
For example: A spring replacement might cost $150–$300, while a full door replacement could be $1,000–$4,000+, depending on the style and material.
When Replacement Might Be the Smarter Move
-
Extensive damage to multiple panels or the door frame.
-
Outdated or inefficient models—especially if your door lacks insulation and your garage is attached to your home.
-
Frequent repairs are adding up and becoming a money pit.
-
You want to upgrade the curb appeal or increase your home’s value (garage doors have a great ROI).
Benefits of Replacing Your Garage Door
When it comes to replacement, you’re not just solving a problem — you’re upgrading your home.
Enhanced Security
Modern garage doors come equipped with smart security features, stronger materials, and tamper-resistant locks that help protect your home from break-ins.
Smart Technology Integration
Newer systems offer compatibility with smart home devices, allowing you to control your door from your smartphone, get notifications, and even schedule openings or closings.
Improved Noise Reduction
Older garage doors and openers tend to be noisy. New systems operate quietly and efficiently, making a huge difference if your garage is attached to your home.
Increased Home Value
According to national reports, a new garage door offers one of the best returns on investment in terms of home improvements. Buyers notice it — and they love it.
Repair or Replace FAQs
It's advisable to have a professional garage door safety inspection annually. This inspection can catch potential problems early and address them before they escalate into major issues, saving you time and money in the long run.
Generally, a well-maintained garage door can last 15 to 30 years. However, if your garage door is approaching this age and experiencing frequent issues, it may be more cost-effective to invest in a new, efficient garage door rather than continuously repairing an aging one.
You can expect to invest anywhere from $2,500 t0 $8,500+ for a new garage door near Monterey, CA. Custom garage doors may be more depending on the the style you choose, the size of your garage, the materials used, and the complexity of the installation.
Environmental Factors near Monterey and Santa Cruz to Consider
Living near the coast means your garage door faces unique environmental pressures:
-
Salt Air Corrosion: Salt can corrode metal parts faster. If your door is rusting, replacing it with weather-resistant materials like aluminum or vinyl-coated steel can offer long-term protection.
-
Humidity and Mold: Wooden doors may swell or grow mold over time. Opt for moisture-resistant options for durability.
Safety Concerns with an Older Garage Door
Safety should always be a priority when it comes to garage doors, especially for families with children or pets. Older garage doors may lack modern safety features which may be a good reason to replace instead of repair. Some concerns include:
- Lack of Auto-Reverse Feature: Modern garage doors are equipped with sensors that detect objects in their path and automatically reverse the door to prevent accidents.
- Weak Springs or Cables: Older garage doors may have weakened springs or cables that could snap, causing severe injuries or damage.
To address safety concerns, consider upgrading to a newer garage door with enhanced safety features and ensure regular maintenance by a professional to keep your garage door in a safe working condition.
When to Call Aaron Overhead Doors
If you’re unsure whether to repair or replace, your best move is to contact the pros at Aaron Overhead Doors. Our local garage door experts can evaluate the extent of wear, recommend cost-effective solutions, and ensure any repairs are done safely.
For licensed, insured technicians who offer free estimates and same-day service call Aaron Overhead Door at 831-219-8648 or contact us online withe any questions. We also offer warranties on both parts and labor.
